Home > School Meals > What is and Isn't Allowed in a Packed Lunch

What is and Isn't Allowed in a Packed Lunch

By: Sarah Knowles BA, MA - Updated: 5 Nov 2016 | comments*Discuss
 
Packed Lunch Healthy School Children

Some mums these days are going round the bend, trying to decide what to put in their children’s packed lunches. The problem is not always in choosing items your children will actually eat, but in the balancing act involved in being sure you have excluded items their school will confiscate.

State schools, as well as some private schools, have strict rules about what you can and cannot include in a packed lunch. While parents might think these rules are fairly straightforward, they are not.

The problem is made even more difficult by the fact that some schools forbid certain items – such as chocolate and biscuits – but are happy to include them as a regular part of school dinners. So what gives?

Healthy Eating

Most schools have strict healthy eating policies, which seek to encourage pupils to have a well-balanced meal in the middle of their school day. These policies are formulated by drawing on guidance from the government, and taking foods from the five food groups in the right amount as indicated by the average age of the children.

With this in mind, school dinners usually serve milk or water only, and ensure that the meal is healthy, varied and balanced. Schools normally offer varied menus with daily vegetarian options.

This will include the right portions of starch, protein and fresh fruit and veg. It will also include (usually) nutritious puddings, which help to balance out the meal.

Foods to Limit – and Avoid

Most schools have packed lunch policies which seek to educate parents about what types of healthy food to include, including fruit and vegetables, carbohydrate, protein, oily fish, and dairy products.

They also either suggest or mandate which foods should be limited, either to once a week or less. They include:

  • Fatty meat products such as sausage rolls and chipolatas
  • Plain biscuits
Schools also often give out a list of foods that are not allowed inside a packed lunch. In some cases, teachers or school dinner ladies will actually confiscate food from the forbidden list, if found inside a child’s packed lunch. These food items include:

  • Fizzy drinks
  • Crisps
  • Chocolate, including chocolate spread
  • Cakes, sweets and chocolate-covered biscuits

The Conundrum

The problem is that most schools serve puddings, yet ban them from being brought in as part of a packed lunch. “We have a healthy packed lunch code which we ask everyone to follow - children are not allowed chocolate, crisps, cakes, etc.,” says the website of one London primary school. It adds that water “is the only drink allowed.”

Many parents consider this to be hypocritical. There is, however, a rationale behind it all.

Schools say that while they can monitor the contents of school dinners, it is impossible to monitor every packed lunch that children bring to school.

If a child brings crisps, for example, they are unable to ensure that they are part of a meal that is otherwise well-balanced. And if a child is allowed to bring chocolate and crisps – and only eats those two items - they know the meal is not well-balanced at all.

With this in mind, they seek to ban everything not considered healthy. Children who want an occasional pudding, they say, can take school dinners – or have a sweet treat at home at the end of the day.

Value for Money

School dinners are good value for money, and if your child enjoys what is prepared at school, you’re onto a winner. You know your child will have a hot meal every day, and it saves you the time and energy involved in making a packed lunch every morning.

If your children complain that they are not allowed sweet items in their lunch, it’s up to you to explain why. And if they really don’t like watching their friends eat ice cream as part of their school dinner while they munch on a carrot, maybe it’s time they switched.

You might also like...
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice..
Hi My children's school is fee paying and does not allow packed lunches except on medical grounds. My children have religiously motivated reasons for wanting to take packed lunches but this is not considered within the scope of exceptions allowed to the general rule of no packed lunches. Is there any law either at UK level or at European level which covers this situation. I personally believe their human right to freedom of religious expression is being denied. Any advise would be much appreciated. Many thanks
Ken - 5-Nov-16 @ 10:40 PM
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice...
Title:
(never shown)
Firstname:
(never shown)
Surname:
(never shown)
Email:
(never shown)
Nickname:
(shown)
Comment:
Validate:
Enter word:
Latest Comments
  • BecsB
    Re: What to Include in an Appeal
    @Sewa - unfortunately, there is nothing you can do until but wait :(
    18 June 2018
  • Sewa
    Re: What to Include in an Appeal
    Hello, I did appeal to my son for secondary school. My appeal was heard on the 11/05/2018 until now I'm waiting for appeal success…
    16 June 2018
  • Mari
    Re: Placing a Foreign Student in a UK School
    Hi we are considering the idea of relocating to the UK with a 6 years old boy that is starting primary school in…
    15 June 2018
  • annb
    Re: Helping Your Child Fit in Abroad
    My 3 grandchildren are coming to live in UK from Australia my granddaughters birthday is 31August, she should go into yr 8…
    15 June 2018
  • Syd
    Re: Placing a Foreign Student in a UK School
    Hi I'm looking for some guidance on bringing my nephew to complete the rest of his studies in Glasgow, He is from…
    14 June 2018
  • Liv
    Re: School League Tables
    @mumtoowen - yes, I don't like the no phone contact either, but I suppose it is for a reason which is to stop homesickness digging in :(
    8 June 2018
  • Jassie
    Re: Placing a Foreign Student in a UK School
    I shall be studied in uk in high school
    7 June 2018
  • mumtoowen
    Re: School League Tables
    I am dreading my child's first school trip to be honest. I think no phone contact is outrageous. I also do not agree with not giving out the…
    6 June 2018
  • Bec22
    Re: Pupil Referral Units
    Hi my son is 14 and is in his last chance in school, I have found a academy unit to put him in but the school said they cannot fund it, where…
    5 June 2018
  • GetTheRightSchool
    Re: What is Flexi-schooling?
    Flex-Parent - Your Question:I am keen to set up Flex-schooling for my 6 year old girl who struggles with a full day at school.…
    5 June 2018